Out-of-State Seller of Nutritional Supplements Created Nexus in Washington

An out-of-state retailer that sold nutritional supplements in Washington was liable for sales tax and B&O tax because it had substantial nexus with Washington. The company made wholesale sales to retailers and distributors and retail sales through infomercials. Employees of the company traveled to Washington to participate in trade shows, sales staff training, and promotional planningto support its wholesale sales. The company engaged marketing firms to assist in marketing its products in Washington. The marketing firms solicited sales from the taxpayer’s wholesale customers, received orders, and acted as intermediaries with retailers on promotional programs. The taxpayer asserted that the Commerce Clause prohibited Washington from subjecting the retail sales to sales tax. However, due to the company’s substantial physical presence in Washington, the Commerce Clause did not preclude taxation. Regarding liability for B&O tax, the company had substantial nexus because its in-state activities supported its abilities to establish and maintain a market for its goods in Washington. There is no requirement that the activities that create the nexus with the state be connected to specific sales. The company’s wholesale sales and marketing apparatus allowed it to obtain information on Washington’s nutritional products market. Additionally, its wholesale activities created a market for its retail sales, since its sales at grocery and drug stores resulted in phone inquiries from individuals. (Irwin Naturals v. Department of Revenue, The Court of Appeals of Washington, Division One, No. 73966-2-I, July 25, 2016)

Posted on August 22, 2016