Alabama Tax Tribunal Upholds Sales Tax Assessment After Records Prove Unreliable

The Alabama Tax Tribunal upheld a sales tax assessment against Perrin and Son, Inc. after the Alabama Department of Revenue found significant discrepancies between the company’s reported taxable sales and other financial records during an audit.

The Department audited the company for April 2020 through March 2023. Perrin provided sales tax invoices, purchase records, and bank statements as requested by the auditor but did not provide exemption certificates or sales tax licenses for its customers.

In addition to the missing documentation, the Department identified issues with how sales were documented. With one exception, Perrin’s invoices did not separately list sales tax. The company explained that sales tax was included in its prices, plus Perrin claimed many tax-exempt sales were made to landscaping or construction companies. However, the Department could not locate sales tax accounts or exemption certificates for the customers it reviewed.

When the Department compared Perrin’s reported taxable sales against other sources, the differences were substantial. Gross receipts reported on federal income tax returns exceeded reported taxable sales by approximately $6.87 million. Proceeds reported on Forms 1099-K exceeded taxable sales by approximately $1.76 million. After adjusting bank deposits for verified sales tax collected, deposits exceeded reported taxable sales by approximately $7.99 million.

Based on those discrepancies, the Department determined that Perrin’s reported taxable sales figures were unreliable and conducted an indirect audit using bank deposits as the starting point for estimating taxable sales. The Department also removed certain purchases from taxable sales when it was determined Perrin had already paid sales tax to vendors.

Perrin challenged the assessment on both procedural and substantive grounds. The company contended that part or all of the assessment was barred by the statute of limitations because a waiver extending the assessment period expired December 31, 2023, before the preliminary assessment was issued on May 22, 2024.

The Tribunal disagreed. It concluded that Alabama’s six-year limitations period could apply when a taxpayer omits more than 25% of the taxable base stated on a return. The Tribunal also determined that, under Alabama law, the final assessment was presumed correct and that Perrin bore the burden of proving the Department was incorrect. Ultimately, the Tribunal found Perrin had not carried that burden, leaving all months in the audit period open for assessment.

On the merits, Perrin argued that its own calculations showed gross receipts of approximately $12.01 million, while the Department calculated approximately $13.48 million in taxable sales. The Tribunal was not persuaded because Perrin’s underlying gross-receipts figures were themselves in question. They had not been adequately reconciled with federal income tax returns, Forms 1099-K, or bank statements.

The Tribunal also emphasized that Perrin had opportunities to substantiate transactions it claimed were exempt or to identify bank deposits attributable to nontaxable sources. However, it did not provide additional exemption certificates, customers’ sales tax licenses, or evidence establishing that particular deposits represented something other than taxable sales. Ultimately, the Tribunal upheld the $390,819.18 assessment, plus additional accruing interest. No penalties were imposed.

The case illustrates that having records is not necessarily the same as having records that substantiate the sales tax treatment of transactions. Alabama requires taxpayers to maintain records sufficient to determine the correct amount of tax, and the Tribunal found Perrin’s records incomplete or confusing because they did not adequately identify allegedly exempt customers and generally did not separately state sales tax.

(Perrin and Son, Inc. v. State of Alabama Department of Revenue, Ala. Tax Trib., Dkt. No. S. 24-0825-RC (Aug. 13, 2026)

Posted on November 20, 2026